Not very surprising reaction , El-Attar ,the Egyptian who is accused of spying for Israel denied the allegations in court today as soon as the court started
"No sir all this did n't happen, and I deny this"
This was what he said according to the reporters who attended the High court of National security "Emergency"
"I had been in the heart of the Intelligence headquarter ,when I was forced to say those charges"
Well all wise intelligent spies must deny the charges , already I remember Sherif El-Falali case like yesterday and how he and his parents kept defending their sons ,slamming the Intelligence reports and in the end their son was found guilty and now is in jail ,At least El-Falali had his parents beside him
You know I hate to say but I expected this with all the Adly police forces scandals here and there , it must be used by our enemies before our friends and you remember my post about the Canadian Coverage ,and how they hinted that he may face torture
The court was postponed to Wednesday by the way
I will let the images speak first then I will speak later
Well he seemed to be very healthy and clean ,I mean he is in better shape than me now
He looks to take care of his appearance,I don't mean his hair cut but his beard
And can you please tell me why he keeps on doing the victory sign??
You know I believe he is a big slim liar , why ??
I don't understand why the hell the intelligence takes him to their famous headquarter in El-Kobba to force him to say these confessions !! Why they didn't take him to some secret place to force a real pressure ??!! I mean it will be more suitable with the pressure and torture mode ,by the way the Egyptian General intelligence got other places then their headquarter in El-Kobba for sure.
Seriously I consider him a liar because I read more finding about the case in El-Masry Youm from couple days
It turned out that the Egyptian Intelligence knew about him in Turkey when an Iraqi citizen "Yasser Hamadan" "48 years old" went to the Egyptian Consulate in Ankara informing the officials there with his doubts that a young Egyptian Man called "Mohamed El-Attar" whom he met from couple of days may be working for the Israelis on the 3 rd of November 2002
He told them that before a month and 10 days ago he was sitting in cafe popular among the Arabs ,when he found a young man who face and accent seemed to be Egyptian asking him about the location of the nearest Mosque , he answered him after that the young man set beside him and opened a conversation ,he told him about his life in Egypt ,his troubles with his family and why he came to Turkey and so on. "Yasser" did the same thing and told him about himself and his troubles , the wish of his children to return to Iraq and the huge costs of transferring their education there and so on.The conversation took one hour was ended by a promise of another meeting in the same place and telephone number exchanged and so on . The meetings kept on for whole 2 weeks.After those 2 weeks "Hamadan" met a stranger who told him that he can help in his financial problems and the transfer of the kids and so , he knew by coincidence that this "stranger" got the Israeli passport beside the Turkish one ,they exchanged the telephone numbers ,yet "Hamadan" didn't feel comfortable with this "stranger" who seemed to know too much about his life especially this "Stranger" got an Israeli passport and saw him going to the Israeli Embassy. He remembered that he didn't complain to anyone except to the Young Egyptian and thus he called El-Attar and confronted him in the cafe if knew "Joey" {The name of the Stranger" El-Attar panicked and said that he didn't know any Israelis and left immediately , as you notice my dear reader "Hamadan" didn't mention anything related to Israel from near or far he just mentioned "Joey" , the panic of El-Attar was enough to make "Hamadan" head to the Egyptian Consulate to inform that there is something fishy about this young man whose name is Mohamed El-Attar , his father is an air fighter and his brother works in a very sensitive military institute
In 48 hours a team from the intelligence traveled to Turkey to see what was going on and began to follow up this young man and took photographs for him ,then they called "Hamadan" who recognized the Young Man as Mohamed El-Attar after 3 months.
In middle of April 2003 , a young man called "Ali Abd El-Hady" came to the headquarter of State Security investigation in Cairo
I would like to hint here something very important thing , some people especially from the working class don't differentiate between the State Security investigation and General Intelligence , the State Security Investigation follows the interior ministry while the other the General Intelligence follows the National Security which is higher , the first is concerned with the inner security ,while the later is from the whole National security , the first is like the FBI while the later is the CIA,I guess I said this before
Anyhow "Abd El-Hady" a young Egyptian man came from Turkey in a family visit when he went to the State Security Investigation to report about a young Egyptian who saw frequently him going to the Israeli embassy which is located near to his work more than 10 times, already he saw that Egyptian whom he didn't know his name in the gatherings of the Arabs and Egyptians
The intelligence officers received his report and then in a meeting they showed him the photos taken for El-Attar whom he recognized immediately.
After few days later , One of the officers who were assigned in his surveillance informed the intelligence that an Egyptian called "Mohamed Hassan" who is working in a restaurant in Vancouver went to the Egyptian Consulate and said that he saw a Christian young man called "Joseph" who sit with the Arabs and Egyptians in their gathering in Cafes and spoke a lot about their problems promising them to solve those problems through mediators who do it for free, yet none of those who were sit with him knew what he worked and who the mediators were and how they would do it for free , it was unbelievable and suspicious for "Hassan" and the Suspicion grew to the degree of informing the Consulate when he saw him going to the Israeli Embassy.
After the arrest of El-Atter he was confronted with the Egyptian witnesses
Look I said it before and I will say it again , cases can be fabricated in Egypt yet the treason and espionage cases are exceptional ,The Egyptian Intelligence don't need to fabricate cases
Already who is the hell El-Atter so they made up a case for him ???
What the intelligence will gain from the confessions of El-Atter as being Gay and converter ??
And about his torture which is a big lie made an intelligent spy that is him , the intelligence don't need to torture him or anything , already according to the reports he didn't confess immediately , he kept fooling around for three till he said what he said in front of the general attorney of State security
Look this is a real serious his files and reports were transferred to 4 Arab countries Syria,Jordan ,Palestine and Libya
El-Attar is just another traitor like Heba Salim ,Thomas,Elie Cohen and Sherif El-Falali ,these are names of spies caught by the Egyptian intelligence too
Another update : The lawyer who was appointed by the court apologized for completing the case ,this is the second lawyer to do so
Sources:
Al-Jazeera.net: An Egyptian denies spying for Israel
Al-Arabiya : AN Egyptian denies spy for Israel
Link to Egyptian suspect denies spying for Mossad - Israel News, Ynetnews
Zienab it is not good for you to talk about working and educated classes! that sort of differentiation would be disatrous to Egypt. I would even go further and proclaim that it one of the major causes of Egypt's intractable problems......
ReplyDeleteI didn't differentiate between them in a harmful way ,I speak about a reality that I see ,many from the working class Egypt don't differentiate between the intelligence and state's security
ReplyDelete