Some leaders ,if not all of them pay the price of their own decisions ,especially those who are dictators , who do not listen to anyone and do not know the meaning of democracy , who consider their people only as supportive masses that only say their names in pre-organized supporting protests "We sacrifice you with blood and soul" ,those leaders from kings and presidents always make stupid mistakes and take wrong decisions and here I do not mean their decisions that are always against the people and the country , but I mean their own decisions that end their own time , that destroy them.
You see some times those leaders take decisions ignoring its results and consequences that may harm their positions as leaders in the country or even in the world paving the road to their own end
Sometimes signing these decisions is just like signing's one death certificate. It is the trap of dictators for sure especially if they do not listen to their advisors and they do not put their people's anger in their consideration , well re-reading what I have written ,I would say that this is how all dictators act.
These stupid decisions they think the people will accept just like the previous decisions , they believe that as long as the people are passive and quiet fearing from the security forces there is no fear from them , not realizing that there is some point ,there is some time people will not accept to take it anymore ,they have enough and ready to rebel against these dictators , it is just like an accumulated process where you fill a jar till the lid and you insist on filling it till it floods.
Most of these stupid decisions are economic ones , economy that affect people's earnings mainly their daily living from what they eat especially if they already live in a very bad economic situation and many sectors of the society are already living under the poverty line , these economic decisions can be the last straw that will move the hunger revolution which by its turn an introduction to even greater social revolution
Why do dictators make these silly mistakes and why can't they predict the people's reaction ?? As I said they do not put the people in their consideration , they consider them like the dead , you must know dictators usually are isolated from the people and usually thanks to the hypocrite entourage surrounding them they are given another completely different image about the people and their conditions, the rosy image that would please any ruler.
Another important question why I started the post with all that theoretical talk , well first this is not a theoretical talk only , it happened through out history dictators always make decisions that cost them their thrones and sometimes their lives , in the politics category you got already a living example in Pakistan , in the military category you got the Saddam's decisions to invade Kuwait and in the economy category you got the famous Mikhail Gorbachev 's Perestroika and Glasnot which brought down the Soviet Union and made it from history "may be the man is not dictator but was a member in a dictatorship regime" ,the examples are many but I can't remember them all ,those came only in my mind
Second I wrote this long introduction to give you idea in advance of what I am going to say , I am sorry if you do not like it but this how I am expressing my thoughts
Now back to the real World to the land of the pharaohs
For two days now the official and opposition newspapers are circulating news saying that Mubarak is in the process to give his order to his prime minister "Ahmed Nazif" to start cancelling the governmental subsidies of the basic commodities in Egypt
This decision or intention is taken right after the visit of the world bank Chief Robert Zoellick last week and his meeting with President Mubarak as his first visit to Cairo where he stated the international organization is going to aid Egypt in its economic reform "strangely till now we did not complete our economic reform since 1975 open door policy" !!
Some basic economic simplified facts
I-What are the basic subsidies commodities in Egypt ??
- Food : Bread , Oil,Sugar,Wheat,Rise and Milk "including the babies milk"
- Fuel ,Gas tubes and electricity
- Medicine
II-How big is the size of the subsidies in the state budget ??
- Some estimation says it is about 50 million E.P "yes I know it is huge number but wait till you read the rest of the facts"
III-What is the percentage of people in Egypt who are living under 2$ per day according to the UN ??
- 43.9%
IV-What is the percentage of people in Egypt who are living under 1$ per day according to the UN ??
- 3%
V- What is the percentage of people in Egypt who are living under the national poverty line according to the UN??
- 20% already it increased 4% from 2005 "16%" and this is considered a rapid increase in 2 years period
As you see the people who need governmental subsidies are increasing not decreasing and even these percentages some say that it is even higher ,if we are including all the country side especially the upper Egypt ,where we will get even higher numbers
Of course I did not mention other economical indicators like the unemployment rate which is increasing and the inflation rate which returned to increase again in 2007 and so on
Yes it is a burden but we need it, according to the State's budget the Subsidies are equal to 50 million E.P still according to the same government's research these 50 millions are spent on the subsidies but on other stuff for example the fancy cars of the ministers their unneeded expenditures..etc
I know that the world bank wants to help Egypt and I will not suspect their intention to aid Egypt but they will be fooling themselves if they think that there will be an economic reform in Egypt without an equivalent political reform , the world banks knows very well there is no hope as long as this corrupted regime exists , we will be fooling ourselves if we say otherwise
Just for your information the reduction of governmental subsidies started for some time , in a gradually reduction the people did not feel it yet they began to feel the reduction during the Nazif cabinet when they began to reduce it more rapidly and at the same time they started to raise the prices for example like the bread and fuel despite the experts warning that this could lead to a hunger revolution ,and already we experienced this from 20 years ago in what President Sadaat stupidly described as the Intifida of the thieves !!! The famous protests of 1977 had happened because people in day and night found the prices were raised , of course if you read the numbers and prices then ,you will laugh , they were nothing . People were mad because one kilo of meat reached to 1 E.P as a price where as today the cheapest kind of meat is not less than 35 E.P per Kilo in Fayoum not in Cairo !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
From the size of the anger in 1977 experts are warning for even larger and more angrier masses if the prices are raised
Already I do not know how you raise prices without an equal raise in Salary !!!?? The Salary raise they announced from couple of days is not enough
Strangely Mubarak is making the opposite of what his son JR had
promised in the annual convention of NDP from two weeks ago where he appeared as the Savior of the working low classes promising that no one will touch the Subsidies !!!!!!!!!!!
Of course the orders of the world bank are much more important than broken promises .
seriously if Mubarak reduces the subsidies and raises the prices of the basic commodities then he will open on himself the gates of hell , people will not take it anymore , it will be his stupid decision , his signature on a revolution document against his own self !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
My dear Hajaj I did not accept your reply because I did not mention here Iran and I do not know what brings Iran and Saudi Arabia which you do not like despite it is Arabic identity ,in fact I do not what is the relation between the women who can't drive in KSA and the terrible economic situation in EGypt !!!
ReplyDeleteDear Hajaj , more than ever I am convinced that you Amr and if you are Amr please respect my wish and do not come here
ReplyDeletealready you seem that you have not been to Egypt lately so you can comment on what I am speaking about
N.B According to the official and unofficial statement Iran is not the enemy
This might be what the Egyptian people need to rise up and revolt and take their rights and their share of the abundant wealth that is grossly and unevenly distributed amongst the population. Do you have any stats on how much of the population controls the bulk of the wealth?
ReplyDelete@anonymous , I do not have perfect statistics but we can consider them 20% , 20% percent owns 80% of the budget
ReplyDeletealready I knew yesterday that 45 million Egyptians will be harmed if the subsidies are cancelled !!
Is anyone has data or statistics info about those few percentage Egyptian controlling wealth in Egypt; what percentage of tax do they pay to the government ? what the law requires them to do? In the west it is common story to hear about famous, politicians, and wealthy barons go to jail for serious amount of time for scheaming the government of lawful tax payment in proportion to their huge income. When was the last time Egyptian had to go that road, or you mean to tell me they are all honest ..haha.ha !!?
ReplyDeleteI have never thought that may be girls in Egypt had political or culture tendecy like this, your blog make me reconsider this issue any way I presents my regards to your blog which have many angle matchs with my owns, regarding this post you are right but the most importante thing is the benefit of the people not the anyone else whither he was. really i believe that this our honorable country merits much more form us to give it back to it's real position.
ReplyDeleteBest wishs
muhammad
@Ohio ,it depends on whom you mean by wealthy in Egypt , you see from Time to time you read about those footballers and artists who don't pay taxes and the D.A Busted them , of course they do settlements with the taxes in what I consider a public stunt
ReplyDeleteor the wealthy who do not pay anything ,they do not give but take , becausse those wealthy people are the majority !!!
Man they are fighting the new taxation on palaces and resorts already and it is just an idea !!!
some times I feel that these people need someone like Nasser , at least the old A Class was contributing to the society !!!!!!!!
@Mohammad , first thanks and believe there are many girls just like me in Egypt unfortunately what is happening in the country now is the opposite to what you said
Zeinobia; what I was impying for is a taxation system like in the west. Basically over 80% of presidents with any sort of income(even welfare, unemployment insurance ..etc) file a tax form every year. Great percentage of them receive refunds from the government, but at the same time any level of income ouside the deductable boundaries have to pay to the government. This way it's an official document you lie on it it's your documented crime. My recollection of taxes in Egypt as being deducted automatically from your salary (as an employee) other than that forget it. Most wealthy peoples don't pay fair taxes they pay bribes instead. Then, how the government expect to budget for socioeconomic programs in the country? it's fair game for corrupt wealthy Egyptian (ooh. are there honest ones!!!?)
ReplyDelete@Ohio you want the president in Egypt to file for his annual income ??? Mr. This happens in other countries not ours plus already do you know how much this man already take ?? it is a scared secret !!?
ReplyDelete