p.s "This is a bit of old news , but I want to publish it anyway to express my opinion"
What I am going to write about caused and is still causing problem in Egypt .It started in the middle of this Ramdan ,this month when two Egyptian newspapers issued a supplement and an article many Muslims if not the majority of Muslims in the country were very angry of it .
The independent "El-Fagr" "The Dune" published the weekly religious article "Moment of light" for its chief in editor famous "Adel Hamouda" where he criticized boldly the Wife of Prophet Mohamed "PBUH" Lady Aisha accusing her that she was the reason of the division of Muslims in to Sunnis and Shiites and that thousand of Muslims were killed because of her , Hamouda published his weekly article and gave it the title "May Allah forgive you Mother of Believers*"
On the same week , "El-Gad" "Tomorrow" ,the official newspaper of El-Gad liberal party published a supplement for the occasion of Ramdan from 10 pages under the title "The worst 10 personalities in the Islamic history !!!" ,it is so interesting and shocking , so shocking when they include names of Prophet Mohamed "PBUH" friends and his wife lady Aisha !! and it was strange that the 10 pages didn't include the name of the journalists or researchers who participated in doing this supplement !!
Of course you can imagine the size of anger People in Egypt felt , especially this time the insult comes from inside ,not the outside west world. Al-Azhar men became very mad , clerics and scholars became so angry that they asked the attorney general to open an investigation against "El-Gad" and he did ,I don't know how the progress of the investigation reached but this opened another debate between the Muslim scholars and the seculars who believed that these insults are from freedom of Expression and this is an insult of freedom of press ......bla bla bla
Beside the debate between the seculars and clerics , came another thing , the accusation to the Shiite sect and Iran to fund those newspapers ,as it is said that Shiites hate Lady Aisha and other 9 Islamic figures , and of course it turned from religious debate to a political one , the national official newspapers began its crusade against Iran and against Ayman Noor the ex-head of "El-Gad" party who is in jail now unjustly because he dared and stood against Mubarak,already I believe that this was made by the regime to hit two birds with one stone , Noor may be released soon because of his health condition "heart disease and a long time diabetic" ,so public must hate him because already he won lots of sympathy plus to spread the feelings that Shiite Iranians are trying to invade Muslim Sunni Egypt by funding tabloids to publish their hate towards Lady Aisha and friend of Prophet Mohamed "PBUH"
Here I won't speak about this charade for now in this post , here I will speak about Mr. Adel Hamouda, because I found out that it is unfair to put the blame all on "El-Gad" newspaper whose sales rates are going down and down since the arrest of Noor and the battle of leadership in his party ,already he is an ex-leader , and he is not currently the leader of El-Gad ,plus he is in jail now and very sick , so I don't know how they blame him and don't blame those who really operate the party and the newspaper , as I was saying ,it is not fair put all the blame on "El-Gad" and leave Adel Hamouda and his tabloid runaway clean !!!
As a Muslim I found it very provoking and insulting that a man like Hamouda , a dirty cheap journalist who lives from society sex scandal to criticize Lady Aisha , who is he in the first place ?? what is his history ?? My grand dad as a journalist he knew this man and he worked with him in Rosa El-Youssef from couple of years , and he never liked or even respected him till his death , and Adel Hamouda really felt the same , simply because my grand father was a respectable and Hamouda is not . Adel Hamouda was an agent for the Egyptian intelligence in the time of Salah Nasr in 1960s and his mission was to spy on the colleagues from co-journalists ,I remember that my grand father told me that because as a journalist he was working in 1967 and 1968 in the covering the intelligence case investigation, also I read his name among the names that were mentioned in the official investigation documents of the Military attorney general with Safwat El-Sherif "oh yes ,the head of Egyptian house of senates in Mubarak's era !!" , these +18 adults documents were leaked online last year ,some said that the Muslim brotherhood was behind it , some said that Gamal Mubarak and his supporters in the NDP from new guards were behind , for me it doesn't matter ,what matters that the documents were so shocking and they were original
So Hamouda was and is still an agent for the dirty security services whether in Salah Nasr or now ,already he is like Mustafa Bakery , the same specie of journalists , pseudo-opposition to calm down the public using the catharsis policy !! not to forget that he is the godfather of tabloids in Egypt , with nudity pictures and dirty sex adventures starring businessman "x" with star "Y" !!!
Hamouda turned Rosa El-Youssef when he was its chief in editor in to a tabloid magazine , same thing to "Sout El-Oma",strange thing as soon he left and Wael El-Ibrashi became in charge of it , the sales boosted twice !!
You want the latest gossip in the town check "El-Fagr" , you want the latest sex fancy story check "El-fagr"
You know I was afraid that this article can cause a division because the owner of the "El-fagr" is a Christian "Nasif Kazman" , who is also the partner of Gamal Marwan in Melody TV and also is the producer of Ruby's records !! Yet thank God his name is not as famous as Hamouda .
You know it is silly that Hamouda writes in everything from art to politics to economy to religion and history , for God sake is there something this man doesn't know in this universe ??
To the blame on Lady Aisha , I am sorry but Hamouda is not a historian
with my all respect can Hamouda criticize the first lady of Egypt Gamal Mubarak's mother aka Susan Mubarak !!?
* Mother of Believers : Is the title given to the wives of Prophet Mohamed "PBUH" to honor them , it came in the holy Quran
Hi
ReplyDeleteWell i couldnt understant your criticism of Hamouda !! you advocate democracy. then you put a hallo on some figures in the islamic history. No one is devoid from criticism except mohamed. Aisha made big mistakes. she wanted to take her revenge from ali for advicing the prohet to divorce her after the effk incident. osman. favoured bani ummayah. by the way most of the sahabah faught bitterly against eachother. Talha and zobier faught ali and were killed by his folowers. Osman were cut into pices by angry muslims for favouring the ummayads. Ali was killed by the kaarig who considered him sinful for bringng on war to the islamic nation. Omar was killed . rumors say that abou bakr was poisned. omar hated kahlid ibn el walid like hell and his first decision as kaliph was disposing khalid despide of his victories and military competence.khalid borke the leg of omar in wrestling match, thats why omar hated him like hell
omar threatened to burn down the house of Ali with faima inside it if he doesnt support bayeit abou bakr. omar and abou bakr used to disagree with mohamed sala allah alayih wa salam.
by the way i love ali because he is the ideal perconification of the Arabic courage, verility and gentlemanliness. i also love the ummayads. becuae it was because of their beautiful arabic racism. that the arabic language displaced the older ones.. during their times the arabs ruled the entire world . And other races, turks persiands, indians germanics were nothing but slaves for the arabs whether they were muslims or not.
i dont like the ABBASYDS FOR GIVING THE PERSIANS AND THE TURKS EQUAL RIGHTS TO THE ARABS. the detrioration of the arabic culture and civlsation started when el mamoun and el moatasim started to rely on trkish slaves as soldiers and persians as statemen. they stopped relying on the gentlmanly and courageous arabic tribes "tamim, bakr , okail, saad, taghloub, lahm, tayaa. because the arabs are very free and noble inside their hearts and totally unruly. what happend afterwards . the arabic empire was deconstructed, opening the door for the seljuke turks invasion in 1040 ( cousins of the mongols) who turned the caliph into a puppy. then opening the door for the turko-mongol inavasion in 1260.....
Hi Amr
ReplyDeletefirst,is this Amr El-Abyd !!??
second about putting hallo on some figure in the Islamic history , I am sorry but this honorable lady is not some figure in the Islamic history , as you mention the Ifaak incident ,why didn't you mention that Surat Baraa came to earth to announce that she was innocent ,I don't think that God would dedicate a part of Sura in Quran to her and she is a bad person who causes the death of thousand muslims , I am sorry I don't buy
About ummyads , oh yes they did great things and so but I don't like them because I blame them on bringing the monarchy back to Islam , you see Islam doesn't recommend the monarchy system , the first four caliphes were chosen by a system near to the elections
I blame the ummyads for the Hagag Youssef
the dictators in Islamic history
another there is no difference between an Arab and a foreign except by faith and the faith is in the heart
yes am Amr el abyad. But aisha faught ali bitterly, and after his death, she said in a confirmed story by most islamic historians "check it out please". only now i can be happy
ReplyDeletecheers
Amre el-abyad
I don't believe ya Amr
ReplyDeleteplus don't you think that you are acting in the same way the Shiites act towards Lady Aisha from hate
they hate her too much as far as I read and heard !!
Well, it seems that you want manuplate historical facts to suit your pre set propositions!!!
ReplyDeletein the "gamal battle" check the tabry and ibn katheer. one of ali followers struck her camel on top of which she was charging her followers against ali. she fell down, then was called names by one of his followers . Ali killed him immedietly escorted her to her house. made confined in there not leave it ever.
by the way, you have absolutly no right whatsoever to read muy mind. Firt of all i dont hate the shiites, as am very secular. Howver i hate the dirty iran. and i hate the shiiets who set their sectarian identity over their nationalistic one. that's why despise the ignorant, demagogic, stupid, medival, grudgy traitor of arb natinalism hasan nasrallah, hakim and sistany..........
and i was not trying to make you hate the shiaa. i was just trying to expose the contrdiction you exhibit when you try to preach democracy instead of watching Kevin Costner "body guard" haaaaa. while trying impose an angelic image of humnan history.
so basically, you dont reply to anything i say. You just take as a perconal matter, my opinion or your opinion. A very undemocratic behaviour. That,s the way the aRABS ARE. wE OFTEN GET MIXEED UP BETWEN THE REALITY OUTTHERE AND the reality we wish it would have been.
we are incapable of critiscing ourselves. Democracy is not a political process my lady zienab, by the way, i like your name :)))))). Anyway, Democracy is a culture that takes its premises on the individual level.
what do you have to say about talha , zobier, ali,omar, osman , khalid.......etc fighting eachother.
the first muslims were more democratic they were criticising and using the sword against eachother to settle their difference. And no one was holy for them. Even the prohet mohamed sala allah alieh wa salam. for instance, el a3rab once grabed his cloth and pushed because they didnt like the fact that he gave the mohajereen more more share from the war gains. check " al-shaykhan taha hussien" and that incident is proven in all their
What's to say ???
ReplyDelete@amr "No one is devoid from criticism except mohamed."
ReplyDeleteIncluding Mohamed.